Advance Subscription Agreement US Reporting: How a UK ASA Shows Up on American Returns
UK startups often raise seed money on advance subscription agreements before the shares exist. If the founder or an investor is American, that gap creates US filing questions on Form 5471, Form 8938, Form 926 and the PFIC rules.

Seed rounds in British startups are often agreed months before any shares exist, and that waiting period is where the American filing questions start.
Written by the US UK Tax Experts team, cross-border tax specialists
Advance subscription agreement US reporting: an introduction
Advance subscription agreement US reporting means showing UK seed money on American returns before the shares exist. For a US-citizen founder, the cash usually appears on the company's Form 5471. For a US-person investor, it can trigger Form 8938, Form 926 and questions under the PFIC rules. The IRS has never said whether an ASA is debt or equity, so consistency matters more than usual.
This article supports our pillar guide on US UK tax for founders and executives. That guide sets out what an American running a British company files each year. For the company-level form in detail, see our guide to Form 5471 for a UK company. Here we stay on one narrow question: the months between signing an ASA and allotting the shares.
Why advance subscription agreement US questions keep arising
British seed rounds are built around SEIS and EIS. Investors want the income tax relief, so founders use an ASA to bank the money now and issue shares later. That suits HMRC's timetable. However, nothing in an ASA is drafted with an American return in mind. Picture a founder in Bristol or an angel in Edinburgh with a US passport. The paperwork fits no obvious box on a US form. That is where advance subscription agreement US questions begin.
Terms used in this guide
An advance subscription agreement (ASA) is a contract to pay now for shares issued later. A long-stop date is the latest date by which those shares must be issued. SEIS is the Seed Enterprise Investment Scheme, and EIS is the Enterprise Investment Scheme. A controlled foreign corporation (CFC) is a foreign company more than half owned by 10% US shareholders. A PFIC is a passive foreign investment company, one that fails a passive income or asset test.
What does HMRC require of an ASA?
HMRC accepts an ASA for SEIS or EIS only on strict terms. The money cannot be refunded, the deal cannot be changed or assigned, and no interest is charged. A long-stop date must also be fixed. HMRC generally expects that date to fall within six months of signing. Relief starts only when the shares are actually issued.
The four core conditions
The SEIS page of HMRC's manual, VCM33025 on advance subscription agreements, lists the tests. The payment must not be refundable in any circumstances. The agreement must not be capable of variation, cancellation or assignment. It must carry no interest. It must name a long-stop date for issuing the shares. The EIS equivalent, VCM12025, repeats the same four points. Both pages add that the payment must not in effect be a loan.
The six-month long-stop date
HMRC generally expects shares within six months of signing. It is unlikely to give advance assurance for a longer period. Even so, a longer date does not on its own make the shares ineligible when the compliance statement is filed. In other words, six months is HMRC's working expectation rather than a statutory bar. Founders who want certainty usually keep within it.
Advance assurance and the date relief begins
Advance assurance is HMRC's informal view that a share issue should qualify. According to VCM60270 on advance assurance, you seek it before signing the ASA. It does not guarantee the company keeps qualifying. Relief is available only from the date the shares are issued. Consequently, the UK and US clocks can both start at that later date. That helps when you line the two returns up.
The size limits that shape the round
The GOV.UK guidance on applying for SEIS caps SEIS money raised at £250,000. The company's gross assets must not exceed £350,000 when the shares are issued. It also needs fewer than 25 full-time equivalent employees. These limits explain why so many ASAs are small, fast and signed by a handful of angels.
Is an ASA debt or equity for US tax purposes?
Nobody can say for certain. The IRS has issued no ruling on British ASAs. The nearest American instrument, the SAFE, has no published guidance either. Most preparers treat a compliant ASA as equity, or as a prepaid contract for equity. It pays no interest and cannot be repaid. Whichever view you take, apply it the same way on every return.
The section 385 factors
Section 385 of the Internal Revenue Code lets Treasury write rules separating debt from stock. The statute, set out by Cornell's text of 26 USC 385, lists the factors those rules may weigh. They include an unconditional promise to pay a sum certain, and subordination. The debt-to-equity ratio, convertibility and links to existing shares also count. An HMRC-compliant ASA has no promise to repay and no interest. Therefore, most of the debt markers are missing.
Why the answer still matters
The label changes several figures in advance subscription agreement US reporting. Treated as equity, the cash sits in capital. The investor may then count as a shareholder from payment. Treated as debt, the company shows a liability and the investor holds a foreign contract. That affects the Form 5471 balance sheet, the investor's Form 8938 description and possibly when a PFIC holding period starts.
The consistency rule in section 385(c)
Under section 385(c), the issuer's label binds the issuer and every holder. A holder may take a different position only by disclosing it on their return. The IRS itself is not bound. Accordingly, the cautious approach is simple. Agree one advance subscription agreement US treatment with every American investor, write it down, and follow it.

How does a US founder's company report the ASA on Form 5471?
The ASA money enters the company's accounts, which feed Schedules C and F of Form 5471. The founder files the form if they control the company or are a US shareholder of a CFC. Describe the balance using the agreed advance subscription agreement US characterisation.
Which founders file
The Form 5471 instructions define a Category 4 filer as a US person with control. That means more than 50% of vote or value. A Category 5 filer is a US shareholder, owning 10% or more, of a CFC. A Category 3 filer is someone who acquires stock taking them to the 10% line. A typical solo American founder is both Category 4 and Category 5. Our article on the annual filings for founders walks through the full set.
Showing the cash on Schedule F
Schedule F is the balance sheet in US dollars. Suppose the UK accounts show the ASA money as shares to be issued, within equity. On an equity reading, it then belongs with capital. If the accounts show it as a liability, you will need a note reconciling the two treatments. For example, a March year end may arrive before any shares are allotted. The balance sheet must still add up on both readings.
Dilution and the category tests
Once the shares are issued, the founder's percentage falls. A founder at 60% before the round may drop to 52% afterwards and still keep control. However, a larger round can pull a founder under 50%. In that case Category 4 may fall away while Category 5 continues, provided US shareholders still own more than half. Track the cap table at each year end. In advance subscription agreement US work, categories follow that year's facts.
Penalties for getting it wrong
The instructions set a $10,000 penalty per company, per year, for a late or incomplete Form 5471. A further $10,000 can follow for each 30 days of delay after an IRS notice, up to $50,000. Therefore, an untidy balance sheet is more than a cosmetic problem. An unexplained gap between UK accounts and Schedule F invites questions.
What does a US-person investor file?
An American investor may need Form 8938 and, above set limits, Form 926. The PFIC rules come next. Advance subscription agreement US reporting works only if the investor's preparer uses the company's characterisation.
Form 8938 for a contract or a shareholding
The Form 8938 instructions list foreign company stock held outside a financial account as a reportable asset. They also cover a financial instrument or contract with a non-US issuer or counterparty. So an ASA is reportable on either reading. A single filer living abroad files above $200,000 at the year end or $300,000 at any time. Married couples filing jointly abroad have thresholds of $400,000 and $600,000.
Form 926 for cash paid to a foreign company
The Form 926 instructions cover cash paid to a foreign company in two cases. One is holding at least 10% of its vote or value immediately afterwards. The other is paying it more than $100,000 in the 12 months ending on the transfer date. The penalty for missing it is 10% of the amount transferred, capped at $100,000 unless the failure was intentional. When an ASA is paid in one year and shares are issued in the next, the timing is debatable. Filing for the year the cash left costs little and closes the point.
Valuing in dollars
Both forms need dollar figures. For Form 8938, the instructions convert foreign-currency assets at the rate on the last day of the tax year. The Treasury reporting rates of exchange are the usual source. For Form 926, the transfer is measured when the cash moves. Keep the bank confirmation of the sterling payment. It anchors your advance subscription agreement US figures.
Could the UK startup be a PFIC for an American investor?
Possibly, in its early years. A newly funded company often holds little except cash and earns little revenue, which can fail the asset test. A start-up exception may protect the first year with gross income. A founder who is a US shareholder of a CFC is usually outside the PFIC rules for that stock.
The income and asset tests
Under 26 USC 1297, a company is a PFIC if 75% or more of its income is passive. It is also one if at least 50% of its assets, on average, are passive. A seed company that has just banked its round may have almost nothing but cash on the balance sheet. For a deeper look at the regime, read our guide to PFIC rules for UK funds.
Why cash is the problem
Cash earning interest is a passive asset under the long-standing approach. The final regulations in Treasury Decision 9936 left the treatment of working capital open for further study. As a result, there is no settled exception for an operating company's spending money. The cautious approach treats the cash as passive. Test the company each year in any advance subscription agreement US file.
The start-up exception
Section 1298(b)(2), shown in Cornell's text of 26 USC 1298, covers the first year with gross income. No predecessor may have been a PFIC. The company must also show, and prove, it is not a PFIC in the next two years. The exception cannot be relied on in advance. You confirm it with hindsight, two years later.
The CFC overlap rule and the Form 8621 threshold
The Form 8621 instructions say a US shareholder of a CFC is generally outside the PFIC rules for that stock. That protects a founder holding 10% or more of a CFC. A smaller American investor gets no such shelter. They can skip Part I of Form 8621 only below a value threshold. All their PFIC stock must be worth $25,000 or less at the year end, or $50,000 jointly. No excess distribution or gain may arise.
A worked example: Hannah's seed round
Consider a typical case. Hannah is a US citizen living in Bristol. She owns 100% of a UK software company with a 31 March year end. In November she signs SEIS-compliant ASAs with three angels for £150,000 in total, with a six-month long-stop. One angel, Tom, is an American living in London who puts in £60,000. The shares are issued in February after advance assurance arrives.
Hannah's side
After the round Hannah holds 70%, so she remains a Category 4 and Category 5 filer. Her preparer and Tom's agree one advance subscription agreement US approach: equity from payment. The company's Form 5471 Schedule F therefore shows the £150,000 within capital, converted at the year-end rate. The CFC overlap rule means the PFIC tests do not touch her shares.
Tom's side
Tom ends with 12%. Using an assumed rate of $1.30 for illustration, his £60,000 is $78,000, under the $100,000 cash test. However, his holding passes 10% once the shares are issued, so Form 926 is needed. At 12% of a CFC he is a US shareholder too. So he files Form 5471 as a Category 3 and 5 filer. His other foreign assets take him past $200,000, so the shares go on Form 8938 too. Had he held 8%, the PFIC tests would have been his main worry.
How US UK Tax Experts can help
US UK Tax Experts prepares advance subscription agreement US filings from one file. The company's Form 5471 and each investor's forms then agree. We read the ASA, agree a characterisation and convert the figures. Then we prepare Forms 5471, 8938, 926 and any 8621. Our US federal returns service covers the founder's own 1040. We prepare and file returns only; we do not advise on whether to invest or how to structure the round.
Conclusion
An ASA solves a UK problem neatly. Yet the IRS has never classified it. The fix is practical rather than clever. Agree the advance subscription agreement US treatment and record it. Then carry it through every form until the shares are issued. Then test the company for PFIC status each year while it is still cash-rich.
Contact us
Raising on ASAs with an American founder or investor in the round? Email hello@usuktaxexperts.com or use our contact form. We reply within one working day.
Frequently asked questions
The IRS has not ruled on it. A compliant ASA pays no interest and cannot be refunded, so most preparers treat it as equity or as a prepaid contract for equity. Agree one view with every party and apply it consistently.
Yes. The cash received under the ASA appears in the company's balance sheet on Schedule F, described according to the agreed characterisation. The issue of shares later can also change your ownership percentage and filing categories.
Only if you meet one of the tests. Form 926 applies to a US person who holds at least 10% of the company immediately after the transfer, or who pays it more than $100,000 in 12 months. The timing between the ASA payment and the share issue is debatable, so many preparers report in the year the cash was paid.
It can be. The Form 8938 instructions cover foreign stock and also financial contracts with a non-US issuer, so an ASA falls within the form on either reading. Whether you file depends on your total foreign assets against the threshold for your filing status and residence.
Yes, for a minority American investor. A company holding mostly cash and earning little income can fail the 50% asset test. A start-up exception may cover its first year with gross income, but it is confirmed only with hindsight.
Not directly; it is an HMRC condition for SEIS and EIS. In practice it decides how long the ASA sits on the balance sheet before shares are allotted, and so whether a year end falls inside the gap. That is when the advance subscription agreement US characterisation has to be shown on a return.





