Exit Tax and UK CGT: Why the Same Gain Can Be Taxed Twice When You Renounce
The US taxes a covered expatriate as if everything were sold the day before renouncing. HMRC waits for a real sale and starts from the original sterling cost. Here is why the two taxes do not line up, and what the treaty does and does not do about it.

A second home in the countryside is the classic asset where the US deemed sale and a later UK sale tax the same growth.
Written by the US UK Tax Experts team, cross-border tax specialists
Exit tax and UK CGT: an introduction
The exit tax and UK CGT do not talk to each other. When a covered expatriate renounces, the US taxes gains as if every asset were sold the day before. Britain treats nothing as sold, so a later real sale is taxed by HMRC from the original sterling cost. Neither country is obliged to credit the other's tax, so the same growth can be taxed twice.
This article supports our pillar on the US-UK double taxation treaty, because the treaty is where most people expect relief. Renunciation work itself sits with our expatriation service. Here we set out where the gap arises, which assets it affects, and how both returns are prepared.
Who meets the exit tax and UK CGT overlap
The overlap only matters if you are a covered expatriate and remain UK resident after renouncing. That describes many long-settled Americans in Britain with a second home, a share portfolio or a stake in a company. People below the covered expatriate tests pay no mark-to-market tax, so they never meet the problem.
Terms used in this guide
The exit tax is the mark-to-market charge in 26 U.S.C. section 877A. A covered expatriate is someone caught by its income, net worth or certification tests. UK CGT is capital gains tax on disposals by UK residents. Base cost is what HMRC lets you deduct from the sale price, usually what you paid plus certain costs.
Why do the exit tax and UK CGT not line up?
They are triggered by different events and measured in different currencies. The US charge falls on a deemed sale at renunciation, in dollars. The UK charge falls on an actual sale, possibly years later, in sterling. Nothing in either system moves one onto the other's timetable.
The US deemed sale
Section 877A treats a covered expatriate's property as sold for its fair market value on the day before the expatriation date. Gains above an exclusion amount are taxed on the final US return. Notice 2009-85 explains how the exclusion is shared across assets and how US basis is then adjusted. The Form 8854 instructions show where each gain is reported.
No disposal for HMRC
UK capital gains tax needs a disposal, such as a sale or gift. Giving up a nationality is not a disposal of anything. So HMRC sees no event when you renounce, and your UK base cost stays at what you originally paid. When you later sell as a UK resident, the whole sterling gain since purchase is in charge. GOV.UK lists the current Capital Gains Tax rates.
Dollars against sterling
The US measures gain in dollars, using exchange rates at purchase and on the day before expatriation. HMRC measures gain in pounds. If sterling fell against the dollar while you owned the asset, the dollar gain is smaller than the sterling gain. If sterling rose, the opposite happens. So the exit tax and UK CGT rarely tax the same number, even on the same house.
Does the US-UK treaty give relief for the exit tax?
Not in any reliable way. The treaty has no rule letting a departing citizen reset the UK base cost to market value. Its credit rules assume both countries tax the same gain in the same period, which is not what happens here.
What Article 13 says
We read Article 13 of the UK-US double taxation convention for any election to treat property as sold and reacquired on a change of status. It contains none. Its paragraph 6 deals with a different case: gains by someone who left one country within the previous six years. So the exit tax and UK CGT overlap is not solved by the gains article.
Article 24 and the timing problem
Article 24(6) gives relief where the US taxes a citizen or former citizen living in the UK under the saving clause. The US then credits UK tax on the same income. At renunciation, though, no UK tax is paid on the deemed gain, so there is nothing to credit. Once you have renounced, the US generally stops taxing your later UK gains. The credit mechanism therefore never meets the right pair of taxes.
A UK credit for the US exit tax?
UK law allows relief for foreign tax on the same gain, explained in HMRC's helpsheet on relief for foreign tax paid. Whether HMRC would credit exit tax paid years before a UK sale is unsettled. We have found no HMRC guidance addressing it. The cautious assumption, and the one we use when modelling, is that no UK credit is given. HMRC's relief normally looks for foreign tax charged on the same gain, and it caps the credit at the UK tax on that gain. A US charge on a deemed sale, paid years earlier and measured in dollars, is a poor fit for that test.
Which assets create the double tax?
The overlap bites on assets HMRC will tax when sold but the US taxes at renunciation. Second homes, let property, shares in a UK company and investments outside an ISA are the usual examples. Some assets are taxed by only one country, which creates a cost but not double tax.
Second homes and let property
A cottage, a buy-to-let flat or a holiday home is the clearest exit tax and UK CGT case. The US taxes the growth at renunciation, after the exclusion. HMRC later taxes the full sterling gain on sale. A UK resident selling residential property must also report and pay within 60 days of completion.

Your main home
HMRC usually exempts a gain on your only or main home, as GOV.UK explains under tax when you sell your home. So the main home rarely suffers double tax. However, the US deemed sale still reaches it, after the exclusion. The cost there is a single US tax with no UK tax to set against it.
Company shares and portfolios
Shares in your own UK company and investments held outside ISAs are taxed by HMRC on sale. They are also caught by the deemed sale. ISAs are different: HMRC never taxes their gains, so any US charge stands alone. UK pensions follow separate US rules for deferred compensation and do not enter the deemed sale.
Consider a typical case: a Cotswold cottage and a share portfolio
Consider a typical case. Graham is a US citizen who has lived in Oxford for 25 years. He renounces in November 2026 and is covered because his net worth exceeds $2 million. The figures are illustrative only, not from a real client.
The US side
Graham bought a Cotswold cottage in 2008 for £250,000, when the pound bought about $2.00. His dollar basis is $500,000. The day before renouncing, the cottage is worth £850,000, or $1,105,000 at $1.30. The deemed gain is $605,000. His portfolio adds another $800,000 of gain. The 2026 exclusion of $910,000, from Revenue Procedure 2025-32, is shared by gain. The cottage takes about $391,900, leaving about $213,100 taxed.
The UK side, three years later
In 2029 Graham sells the cottage for £900,000. HMRC computes the gain from his original £250,000 cost, ignoring the US deemed sale. Leaving costs aside, the gain is £650,000. After the £3,000 annual exempt amount, it is taxed at 24% if rates are unchanged. That is about £155,300 of UK CGT, with no credit for the US tax.
Reading the result
On these figures, Graham pays US tax on about $213,100 of deemed gain in 2026. He then pays UK tax on the whole sterling gain in 2029. Part of the same growth has been taxed twice. The falling pound also means HMRC taxes a larger gain than the US measured. This is the exit tax and UK CGT gap in practice.
What do you file in each country?
The US side is filed for the year you renounce. The UK side is filed for the year you sell. Each return stands on its own, and the figures should be kept together so the history is clear later.
The final US return
You file a dual-status return for the year of renunciation, with Form 8854 attached. The deemed gains appear in Part II, Section C of Form 8854 and on the return itself. You may elect to defer the tax on particular assets, which our guide to exit tax deferral in 2027 explains. Deferral changes when you pay, not whether the overlap exists.
The UK return in the year of sale
Nothing is reported to HMRC when you renounce. In the year of sale, you report the gain on your Self Assessment return, and within 60 days for UK residential property. The base cost is your original sterling cost plus allowable costs. The US exit tax is not an allowable cost for HMRC.
Records worth keeping
Keep the purchase completion statement, improvement invoices and the valuation used for the deemed sale. Keep your certificate of loss of nationality and the Form 8854 you filed. If HMRC ever asks why you have a US valuation on file, the papers explain it. Moreover, a later buyer's solicitor may ask for the same history. Convert each figure at the rate for its own date and note the source of every rate. Years later, nobody remembers which rate was used unless it was written down at the time.
Can anything reduce the exit tax and UK CGT overlap?
The exclusion amount absorbs the first slice of US gain, and the main home exemption removes most UK tax on a home. Beyond that, the overlap depends on facts that only modelling reveals. We prepare the figures; we do not advise on whether or when to renounce.
The exclusion does much of the work
For 2026 the exclusion is $910,000, and for 2027 it rises to $940,000 under Revenue Procedure 2026-35. Many renouncers have total gains below that figure. For them, there is no exit tax and UK CGT overlap at all, because no US tax arises. The overlap is a problem mainly for those with large gains. Bear in mind that the exclusion is shared across every asset with a gain. A modest cottage gain can still leave a taxable slice if a large portfolio gain sits beside it, so the whole list of assets matters.
The covered expatriate tests themselves
If you are not covered, there is no deemed sale. Being covered because you cannot certify five years of compliance is avoidable by fixing the past first. Our pillar on IRS streamlined filing explains that route. The net worth and income tests are matters of fact. They are measured at the expatriation date and over the five prior years, so they cannot be fixed after the event. The order of steps, compliance first and renunciation second, is what shapes the result.
The ten-year rule for tax-motivated renunciation
Article 1(6) of the treaty lets the US keep taxing a former citizen for ten years on US-source income, where avoiding tax was a principal purpose. UK property gains are not US-source, so this rarely affects the cottage case. It can matter for US assets held after renouncing. The IRS expatriation tax page summarises the US rules.
How US UK Tax Experts can help
US UK Tax Experts prepares US and UK returns from one file, so the two agree. For the exit tax and UK CGT, we prepare the final US return and Form 8854, including the deemed gain by asset in dollars. Later, we prepare the UK return for the sale from your original sterling cost. Our property gains service and our guide to the US exit tax explain more.
Conclusion
Renouncing triggers a US deemed sale but nothing in Britain. HMRC taxes a later sale on the full sterling gain from your original cost. The treaty has no step-up for departing citizens, and its credit rules do not reach this timing gap. Whether HMRC would credit US exit tax is unsettled, so the cautious approach assumes it will not. For second homes, let property and company shares, the exit tax and UK CGT can tax the same growth twice.
Contact us
If you are thinking about renouncing and own UK property or shares, email hello@usuktaxexperts.com or use our contact page. Send a list of assets with purchase dates and costs. We reply within one working day.
Frequently asked questions
No. Giving up a nationality is not a disposal for UK capital gains tax. HMRC taxes only actual disposals, such as a sale or gift, so nothing is charged in Britain when you renounce.
Yes. The US taxes a covered expatriate on a deemed sale at renunciation, and HMRC later taxes the real sale from your original sterling cost. Neither country is obliged to credit the other's tax, so the exit tax and UK CGT can overlap.
No. Article 13 of the treaty contains no election to treat property as sold and reacquired on renunciation. Your UK base cost stays at what you originally paid.
This is unsettled, and we have found no HMRC guidance on it. Foreign tax credit relief normally needs foreign tax on the same gain, and exit tax is paid years before the UK sale. The cautious approach assumes no credit.
Usually not as double tax. HMRC normally exempts gains on your only or main home, so there is little UK tax. The US deemed sale can still reach the home, after the exclusion amount.
The exclusion is $910,000 for 2026 and $940,000 for 2027. It is shared across all assets with a gain, in proportion to each gain. Many renouncers have total gains below these figures and pay no exit tax.





