US UKTax Experts
All insights
COMPLIANCE9 min read

Form 8938 UK Pension Reporting: Valuing a Pension You Cannot Touch

A UK pension is usually reportable on Form 8938, but the hard part is the number. Here is how a defined contribution pot, a defined benefit scheme and the state pension are each treated, and the cautious approach where the rules leave room.

Grey-haired man in glasses reading a pension letter in a stone cottage, checking his Form 8938 UK pension value

The yearly pension statement is usually the starting point for the figure on Form 8938, even for a scheme you cannot draw on for years.

Written by the US UK Tax Experts team, cross-border tax specialists

Form 8938 UK pension: an introduction

A Form 8938 UK pension entry is usually needed once your foreign assets pass the threshold for people living abroad. You report your interest in the scheme, not the funds it holds. The difficult part is the value. A defined contribution pot has a balance. A defined benefit scheme does not, and the IRS rules leave some room.

This article supports our guide to FBAR and FATCA reporting. It is about the yearly filing for an American in Britain who is up to date. We cover the threshold, each kind of pension and the cautious approach to valuation. We prepare and file the forms; we do not give pension or investment advice.

What Form 8938 UK pension reporting means

Form 8938 is the statement of specified foreign financial assets that some US taxpayers attach to their tax return. It comes from the FATCA rules in section 6038D. The Form 8938 instructions tell you to report your interest in a foreign pension plan in Part VI. They also say you do not report the plan's own assets separately.

Who this guide is for

We write for US citizens and green card holders who live in the UK and belong to a UK pension. That includes workplace schemes, SIPPs and public sector final salary schemes. Typically, readers have filed Form 8938 for bank accounts and now wonder about the pension.

When does a UK pension push you over the Form 8938 threshold?

When your total specified foreign assets exceed the abroad thresholds. For a single person living abroad, that is more than $200,000 at year end or more than $300,000 at any time in the year.

The thresholds for people living abroad

The instructions set higher figures if you meet the presence abroad test. A married couple filing jointly files above $400,000 at year end or $600,000 at any time. A married person filing separately uses the single figures. You meet the test as a bona fide resident abroad for a full tax year, or by 330 full days abroad in 12 months.

The pension counts towards the total

Your pension's value is added to your bank accounts, ISAs and other foreign assets. Consequently, a mid-career pension often takes an American over the line on its own. By contrast, a newly joined workplace scheme rarely does. Remember that you file Form 8938 only if you must file a US income tax return for the year.

The state pension is not reported

The UK state pension is a social security benefit. The instructions say foreign social security equivalents are not specified foreign financial assets. The IRS comparison of Form 8938 and FBAR requirements marks them as not reportable on either form. So your state pension forecast stays off Form 8938, however large it is.

How do you value a defined contribution pension?

Use the fund value. A defined contribution pension, such as a SIPP or most workplace schemes, has an account balance that is its fair market value.

The rule in the instructions

For a pension interest, the instructions say the maximum value is the fair market value of your beneficial interest. For most assets, you may use the year-end value unless it is not a reasonable estimate of the maximum. Therefore, a fund that rose steadily through the year can be reported at its 31 December value. A fund that fell sharply late in the year needs a higher figure from earlier statements.

Where the figures come from

Most providers issue an annual statement and an online balance. Workplace schemes are explained on GOV.UK's page about workplace pensions. Note that UK statements often run to 5 April, while the US year ends on 31 December. In our experience, a screenshot of the balance at the end of December saves a lot of reconstruction later.

Converting to dollars

The instructions direct the Treasury Bureau of the Fiscal Service exchange rate on the last day of the tax year. Treasury publishes these as its reporting rates of exchange. Use the same rate for the pension as for your other Form 8938 assets. Moreover, keep a note of which rate you used each year.

Young oak sapling in a terracotta pot beside two piggy banks, like a Form 8938 UK pension growing untouched
A pension grows for decades before you can draw on it, yet the IRS still asks for a value each year once your assets pass the threshold.

How do you value a defined benefit pension?

This is where the rules leave room. A defined benefit or final salary pension promises an income, not a pot. The instructions offer a fallback when you lack readily accessible information on its value.

The fallback in the instructions

If you do not know the fair market value from readily accessible information, the maximum value is the value of distributions you received in the year. If you received none, the instructions say to use a value of zero. Consequently, a deferred member who has not started drawing may report the interest at zero. The interest is still listed, so the IRS knows it exists.

When a transfer value is readily accessible

A cash equivalent transfer value is the amount a scheme would pay to move your benefits elsewhere. GOV.UK explains how to request one on its page about transferring your pension. Once you hold a recent transfer value, it is arguably readily accessible information about fair market value. No IRS guidance says so directly. However, the cautious Form 8938 UK pension approach is to use it when you have one.

The contested middle ground

Practice differs here, and we say so plainly. Some preparers report every deferred defined benefit scheme at zero. Others estimate a value even without a transfer quote. In our view, the defensible line is to use a figure you actually have. That means zero where no value is available, and the transfer value where one has been issued. Whichever you choose, apply it consistently year to year and note the basis.

A worked example: three pensions, one form

Consider a typical case. It is an example, not a real client, and the exchange rate is assumed. Gareth is a US citizen living in Cardiff and files as single. He has a SIPP, a deferred public sector final salary pension and a state pension forecast. He also holds a cash ISA and a current account.

The figures

His SIPP was worth £180,000 at 31 December and never higher during the year. His ISA held £40,000 and his current account peaked at £25,000. Last spring, his final salary scheme quoted a transfer value of £240,000. Assume an exchange rate of $1.30 to the pound. On those figures, the SIPP alone is $234,000.

The filing decision

Gareth lives abroad, so his single threshold is $200,000 at year end. The SIPP alone passes it. He therefore files Form 8938 and lists every specified asset. The SIPP goes in at $234,000. The final salary scheme is the judgement call. Because he holds a recent transfer value, we would report about $312,000 and record the basis. The state pension is left off entirely.

What changes if he had no transfer value

Suppose Gareth had never asked for a transfer quote. He would then have no readily accessible value for the scheme. On the instructions' fallback, with no distributions, its Form 8938 UK pension value would be zero. He would still list it, because the interest exists. We show both versions to illustrate the rule, not to suggest requesting or avoiding a quote.

What changes once you start drawing a pension?

The valuation basis can change. Once payments begin, a defined benefit scheme has distributions to measure, and a drawdown pot keeps its balance.

A final salary pension in payment

Consider a scheme that now pays you an income. If you still lack readily accessible information on its fair market value, the fallback uses the payments themselves. The maximum value is then the value of cash distributed to you in the year. So a pension paying £20,000 a year would be reported at that amount, converted to dollars. Consequently, a Form 8938 UK pension value can rise sharply in the first year of payment, even though nothing about the scheme has changed.

Drawdown and the tax-free lump sum

A drawdown pot is still a defined contribution fund, so you report its balance. In a year you take a tax-free lump sum, the highest value usually comes just before the payment. Therefore, check the balance on the day before the withdrawal, not only at year end. The lump sum itself raises a separate US tax question, covered in our guide to the UK pension lump sum and US tax.

Transfers between schemes

Moving a pot from one provider to another during the year leaves two interests to consider. Each was held at some point in the year. In our experience, the clearest Form 8938 UK pension approach is to list both, each at its highest value while you held it. Additionally, keep the transfer confirmation, because it shows the dates and amounts.

How does Form 8938 sit with the FBAR and the treaty?

They are separate duties. Reporting the pension on Form 8938 does not change its tax treatment, and it does not replace the FBAR.

The FBAR has its own rules

The FBAR is filed with FinCEN, not with your return. It uses the maximum account value in the currency of the account. Many UK pensions are also reported on it, and our guide to UK pensions on the FBAR covers that side. The FinCEN FBAR page sets out the basics.

The treaty affects tax, not reporting

Article 18 of the US-UK tax treaty stops the US taxing growth inside a UK pension until you draw from it. Yet it says nothing about information returns. Therefore, a Form 8938 UK pension entry is needed even when the growth is not taxed. Our guide to UK pension US tax covers the tax side.

Forms that can replace the entry

The instructions excuse an asset reported on a timely Form 3520, 5471, 8621 or 8865. You must still list those forms on Form 8938. Whether a UK pension belongs on Form 3520 is itself debated. In our experience, most workplace and personal pensions are not reported on it. Additionally, if you do file one, note it in the right part of Form 8938.

What are the penalties for leaving a pension off?

The instructions describe a $10,000 penalty for failing to file a complete and correct Form 8938. A further penalty of up to $50,000 applies for a continuing failure after IRS notice.

Incomplete as well as late

The penalty applies to an incomplete form, not just a missing one. So a Form 8938 that lists your bank accounts but omits a pension can still be a failure. Furthermore, section 6501(c)(8) keeps the assessment period open until three years after the missing information is supplied. Our Form 8938 guide for Americans abroad covers the wider form.

Putting earlier years right

If you missed a pension in earlier years, the route depends on why. Where returns were also missed and the failure was non-wilful, the streamlined procedures may fit. Our IRS streamlined filing guide explains who qualifies.

How US UK Tax Experts can help

US UK Tax Experts prepares your US and UK returns from one file, so your pension figures agree across both. For a Form 8938 UK pension entry, we gather each scheme's statement, apply the right valuation basis and convert at the Treasury rate. In addition, we record the basis for any defined benefit value so it is consistent each year. Our pension reporting service and FBAR and FATCA service cover both reports.

Conclusion

A UK pension usually belongs on Form 8938 once your assets pass the abroad threshold. A defined contribution pot is valued at its balance. A defined benefit scheme can be valued at zero without readily accessible information, but a recent transfer value changes that. The state pension stays off the form. So gather the statements in December, choose a basis and keep to it.

Contact us

Not sure what value to give your UK pension? Email us at hello@usuktaxexperts.com or use our contact form. Send your latest pension statements and last US return. We reply within one working day.

Frequently asked questions

Usually yes, once your specified foreign assets exceed the threshold. The instructions say to report your interest in a foreign pension plan in Part VI, without listing the plan's own investments. You file only if you must file a US tax return for the year.

No, the state pension is not a Form 8938 UK pension entry. Foreign social security equivalents are not specified foreign financial assets. The IRS marks them as not reportable on Form 8938 or the FBAR.

For a single filer who meets the presence abroad test, more than $200,000 at year end or more than $300,000 at any time. For a married couple filing jointly, it is more than $400,000 at year end or $600,000 at any time. A married person filing separately uses the single figures.

Use its fair market value if you have readily accessible information, such as a recent transfer value. Without it, the instructions say to use distributions received, and zero if there were none. Practice differs, so choose a basis you can support and keep to it.

No. Article 18 stops the US taxing growth inside a UK pension until you draw from it. It does not change information reporting, so the Form 8938 UK pension entry is still needed.

The instructions direct the Treasury Bureau of the Fiscal Service rate on the last day of the tax year. Use that rate even if the pension's highest value came earlier in the year.

The instructions describe a $10,000 penalty for failing to file a complete and correct form. A further penalty of up to $50,000 applies for a continuing failure after IRS notice. An omitted asset can also extend the IRS assessment period.

Have a question this does not answer?

Tell us the situation and we will tell you what needs filing, where, and by when.