US UKTax Experts
All insights
US TAX12 min read

Help to Save US Tax: The Government Bonus on Your US Return

Help to Save pays a 50% government bonus to working Universal Credit claimants, tax-free in the UK. For a US citizen the bonus is a grey area. Here is how to decide whether to report it, which year it belongs to, and how the account fits your FBAR.

Young woman drops coins into a glass jar by her kettle, building savings that bring Help to Save US tax rules into play

Fifty pounds a month into Help to Save earns a UK bonus, and the US return then has to decide what that bonus is.

Written by the US UK Tax Experts team, cross-border tax specialists

Help to Save US tax: an introduction

The short answer on Help to Save US tax treatment is that nobody knows for certain, because the IRS has never ruled on the UK bonus. There is a respectable argument that it is excluded welfare. There is also a plain-reading argument that it is income. Our cautious approach is to report the bonus in the year it reaches your bank, or to disclose a decision not to.

This article supports our guide to FBAR and FATCA reporting, because the account itself is a foreign account for US purposes. Our FBAR and FATCA service prepares those forms. We prepare and file returns; we do not give benefits or savings advice.

Why Help to Save US tax treatment differs from an ISA

Most writing on this scheme is aimed at UK savers, and it rightly says the bonus is tax-free. US commentary, meanwhile, focuses on ISAs and the Lifetime ISA. None of it tests the Help to Save bonus against the US rule for need-based welfare. That test is the heart of the matter, because this scheme, unlike an ISA, is open only to people on a means-tested benefit.

What is Help to Save and who can open one?

Help to Save is a UK government savings account for working people on Universal Credit. You save up to £50 a month and the government adds 50p for every £1 you save, paid in two bonuses over four years.

Eligibility today

The GOV.UK Help to Save eligibility page sets two main tests. You must be receiving Universal Credit, and you, or you and your partner on a joint claim, must have had take-home pay of £1 or more in your last monthly assessment period. You must also live in the UK. Each partner applies for their own account.

The £1 test is recent. A policy paper on the eligibility change confirms that from 6 April 2025 any working Universal Credit claimant qualifies. Before that, you needed earnings equal to 16 hours a week at the National Living Wage.

The scheme is now permanent

HMRC announced on 21 September 2026 that Help to Save has been made permanent, after earlier extensions to April 2025 and April 2027. The same announcement says eligibility will widen from 2028 to all Universal Credit claimants. It also plans a move to several providers, so banks and credit unions can offer accounts. No bonus changes were announced.

Who runs the account

HMRC runs the scheme and checks eligibility. National Savings and Investments, known as NS&I, is the account provider. HMRC's Help to Save technical manual names NS&I as the provider that pays any bonus due. The legal framework is the Savings (Government Contributions) Act 2017.

How is the Help to Save bonus worked out and paid?

You earn two bonuses: one after year two and one after year four. Each is 50% of growth in your highest balance, and both are paid into your bank account, not the savings account.

The two bonuses

GOV.UK explains what you get from Help to Save. The first bonus is 50% of your highest balance in years one and two. The final bonus is 50% of the amount by which your highest balance in years three and four beats the earlier peak. If your peak does not rise, there is no final bonus. Saving the full £50 every month means £2,400 over four years and bonuses of up to £1,200.

Timing and conditions

The first bonus period is 24 months beginning with the month you open the account, under regulation 13 of the Help-to-Save Accounts Regulations 2018. The account then closes four years after opening. If you close early, you miss the next bonus. Furthermore, you can never open a second account. These conditions matter later for the US timing question.

UK tax treatment

In the UK, the position is simple. GOV.UK describes the payments as two tax-free bonuses over four years. So nothing goes on your Self Assessment return. However, a UK exemption does not bind the IRS. Help to Save US tax treatment follows US rules alone.

Coin jar on a rainy windowsill, small savings that raise Help to Save US tax questions
A few pounds a month builds slowly, yet the bonus and the account both have to be weighed on the US side.

Is the Help to Save bonus taxable in the US?

There is no IRS ruling, so the Help to Save US tax answer is contested. The bonus is either welfare that US law excludes, or ordinary income that it taxes. Both views can be argued in good faith.

The starting point: all income is taxable

Gross income is defined very widely. Section 61 of the Internal Revenue Code taxes income from whatever source derived, unless a rule excludes it. A cash payment from a government, added to your savings, looks like income on that reading. Moreover, a foreign tax exemption has no effect on US gross income.

The argument for exclusion: the general welfare doctrine

The general welfare exclusion is an administrative doctrine that keeps certain government payments out of income. IRS Publication 525 for 2025 tells you not to include governmental benefit payments from a public welfare fund based upon need. Help to Save fits that language better than most UK payments. You can only open an account while on Universal Credit, which is means-tested. The bonus is paid from public funds. Furthermore, it is not payment for services.

The argument against exclusion

The doctrine developed around US federal, state and tribal programmes. The IRS has not said whether it reaches a foreign government's scheme. In addition, the bonus is not measured by need. Instead, it is measured by how much you save, which looks more like a matching contribution than relief. Once you qualify, you also keep the account if your benefit stops. Consequently, a strict reader can say the payment rewards thrift, not hardship. That tension is why Help to Save US tax treatment varies between preparers.

Why the treaty does not settle it

The US-UK double taxation convention does not help a US citizen here. Article 17(3) covers social security payments made by one country to a resident of the other. In this case the UK pays its own resident. Article 22 would give the UK sole taxing rights over other income. However, the saving clause in Article 1(4) lets the US tax its citizens as if the treaty did not exist. Article 22 is not among the exceptions in Article 1(5).

Which year does the bonus belong to on your US return?

If you report it, the bonus belongs to the calendar year in which it is paid into your bank account. It does not build up year by year while you save.

Why there is no accrual

A US citizen filing as an individual is normally a cash-method taxpayer. Under section 451, income is taxed in the year you receive it. The constructive receipt regulation adds that income is not received while your control of it is subject to substantial limitations. During the bonus period you cannot draw the bonus. Moreover, closing the account early forfeits it. So nothing is received until the payment arrives, and the Help to Save US tax question only arises in a bonus year.

The two payment years

Consequently, Help to Save US tax reporting normally touches two separate US years: the year of the first bonus and the year of the final bonus. The dates rarely line up with the UK tax year. An account opened in May pays its first bonus around two years later, in the US year that payment lands. Keep the NS&I bonus statement for each.

Converting to dollars

The IRS guidance on foreign currency and exchange rates says to use the rate prevailing when you receive an item. So the natural rate for a bonus is the one for the day it arrives. The IRS also publishes yearly average currency exchange rates and accepts any posted rate used consistently. FBAR values use a different source, which we cover next.

Does a Help to Save account go on your FBAR?

Yes, in our view it counts. A Help to Save account held with NS&I is a financial account at a UK institution. Its maximum balance joins all your other UK accounts in the $10,000 aggregate test.

The aggregate test

FinCEN's FBAR page says you must file if the aggregate value of your foreign financial accounts exceeds $10,000 at any time in the calendar year. A Help to Save balance cannot exceed £2,400. On its own it never triggers a filing. However, add a current account that peaks on payday, and many households cross the line. The regulation behind the FBAR is 31 CFR 1010.350.

Due date and exchange rate

The IRS FBAR page gives a due date of 15 April, with an automatic extension to 15 October. FinCEN's note on reporting maximum account value says each maximum is converted at the Treasury rate for the last day of the year. Treasury publishes these on its Treasury Reporting Rates of Exchange page. Our article on the FBAR exchange rate explains the method.

The bonus lands in another account

Because the bonus goes to your bank account, it raises that account's maximum in the bonus month. So a bonus year can push you over the FBAR line even where earlier years did not. In practice, Help to Save US tax work always includes the bank balance in the weeks after each bonus.

What about Form 8938 and PFIC rules?

Form 8938 is rarely needed for a Help to Save holder, and PFIC rules do not apply at all. The account is cash, and the thresholds for people abroad are high.

Form 8938 thresholds

Form 8938 is the IRS statement of specified foreign financial assets, filed with your return. The IRS comparison of Form 8938 and FBAR requirements sets the thresholds for people living abroad. A single filer reports above $200,000 at year end or $300,000 at any time. For a joint return, the figures are $400,000 and $600,000. Someone eligible for Help to Save will seldom reach them. Even so, Help to Save US tax reporting should include the account in the total if you do.

Why it is not a PFIC

A passive foreign investment company, or PFIC, is a foreign corporation that mostly earns or holds passive assets. The test in section 1297 applies to shares in a corporation. A Help to Save account holds cash and buys no fund units. Therefore, no Form 8621 is needed, unlike many stocks and shares ISAs. Our guide to ISA US tax reporting covers the contrast.

Does Universal Credit itself count on your US return?

Universal Credit has a stronger claim to exclusion than the Help to Save bonus. It is a means-tested payment for living costs, which sits close to the Publication 525 wording. Still, the IRS has not addressed it directly.

What Universal Credit is

GOV.UK describes Universal Credit as a monthly payment to help with living costs if you are on a low income, out of work or cannot work. The amount falls as your earnings rise. That design, based on need and paid from public funds, is what the general welfare exclusion looks for.

The cautious approach

In our experience, many preparers leave Universal Credit off the US return as need-based welfare. We think that position is reasonable, but it is a position. Where we exclude it, we record why in the file. For more certainty, you can disclose a position on Form 8275. For Help to Save US tax purposes, the bonus is the weaker case of the two. Our article on UK Child Benefit and US tax explains why a payment that is not means-tested is harder to exclude.

A worked example: Megan's two bonuses

Consider a typical case. It is an example, not a real client, and the figures are illustrative. Megan is a US citizen working part-time in a Leeds café. She claims Universal Credit and earns about £11,000 a year. She opens a Help to Save account in May 2025 and saves £50 every month.

Her bonuses and the US years

By April 2027 her highest balance is £1,200, so her first bonus is £600, paid in May 2027. That is a 2027 US item. By April 2029 her balance peaks at £2,400. The final bonus is 50% of the £1,200 increase, so another £600, paid in May 2029. At an illustrative $1.30 to the pound, each bonus is $780. Her Help to Save US tax position therefore touches 2027 and 2029, not every year.

Her FBAR

Megan's current account peaks at £4,800 on payday and she keeps £2,000 in an easy-access account. Add the Help to Save peak, and her aggregate maximum in 2029 is £9,200 plus the £600 bonus in her bank. At the illustrative rate, that exceeds $10,000. So she files an FBAR listing all three accounts, even though none alone comes close.

Her tax and the exclusion trap

The UK charges no tax on the bonus, so there is no UK tax to credit against any US tax. If Megan uses the foreign earned income exclusion for her wages, the bonus is not earned income and stays outside it. Under the stacking rule in section 911(f), other income is taxed at the rates that would apply had the excluded wages been included. In Megan's case, her low income means little or no tax either way. We would model both methods.

How to decide your Help to Save US tax position

Work through three questions in order: whether the bonus is income, which year it falls in, and which forms the account triggers. The answers to the second and third do not change with the first.

Step one: choose and record a position

Start with your appetite for risk. If you want the safest Help to Save US tax route, report the bonus as foreign other income in the year paid. If you prefer the welfare argument, exclude it but keep a written note of the reasoning. Where the amount is meaningful, add a disclosure. Either way, apply the same Help to Save US tax treatment to both bonuses.

Step two: fix the years

Find the bonus payment dates on your NS&I statements. Next, place each one in the US calendar year it reached your bank. Then check whether that year's return was already filed. If it was and you now choose to report, an amended return may be needed.

Step three: test the reporting forms

Finally, total the maximum balance of every UK account for each year, including Help to Save. If the total exceeded $10,000, file the FBAR. Then compare year-end and peak totals with the Form 8938 thresholds. Our article on FBAR versus Form 8938 shows how the two overlap.

How US UK Tax Experts can help

US UK Tax Experts prepares the US return, the FBAR and any Form 8938 from one file with your UK figures. We place each Help to Save bonus in the right US year, record the position you choose, and check every UK account against the aggregate test. We also prepare UK returns where you need one, so both countries see the same facts. Our US and UK tax returns guide explains how the two filings fit.

Conclusion

Help to Save gives working Universal Credit claimants a 50% bonus that the UK does not tax. On the US side, the bonus sits between the welfare exclusion and the wide definition of income. The IRS has not chosen between them. Therefore, settle your Help to Save US tax position once, apply it to both bonuses in the years they are paid, and count the account in your FBAR total every year.

Contact us

Saving into Help to Save and unsure what the IRS expects? Email us at hello@usuktaxexperts.com or use our contact form. Tell us when you opened the account and which US returns you have filed. We reply within one working day.

Frequently asked questions

Possibly. The IRS has never ruled on it, so the Help to Save US tax position is contested. One view excludes it as need-based government welfare; the other treats it as income under the wide definition in section 61. The cautious approach is to report it in the year it is paid or to disclose a decision not to.

If you report it, it is income in the calendar year it is paid into your bank account. You cannot draw the bonus during the bonus period and lose it by closing early, so nothing accrues while you save. Most accounts produce two US reporting years, one for each bonus.

Yes. It is a financial account held with NS&I in the UK, so its maximum balance joins your other UK accounts in the $10,000 aggregate test. On its own it cannot exceed £2,400, but combined with a current account it often tips a household over the line.

No. PFIC rules apply to shares in foreign corporations, such as fund units. A Help to Save account holds only cash, so no Form 8621 is needed for it.

Many preparers treat it as excluded, because it is a means-tested payment for living costs from public funds. That fits the IRS wording on welfare based upon need, but the IRS has not addressed Universal Credit directly. Keep a record of the reasoning if you leave it off.

Yes, if you meet the UK tests: you receive Universal Credit, had take-home pay of £1 or more in your last assessment period, and live in the UK. US citizenship does not affect UK eligibility. It only adds the Help to Save US tax and FBAR questions to your US filing.

No. HMRC announced in September 2026 that the scheme has been made permanent. It also plans to widen eligibility from 2028 to all Universal Credit claimants.

Have a question this does not answer?

Tell us the situation and we will tell you what needs filing, where, and by when.