P11D Benefits and US Tax: How UK Perks Show Up on an American Executive's Return
A UK company car, private medical cover or a flat paid for by your employer is taxed in Britain at HMRC's values. The US values the same perks its own way, and some it does not tax at all. Here is how they line up, and what payrolling from April 2027 changes.

Senior roles in London often come with a car, medical cover or housing, and each perk is valued differently by HMRC and the IRS.
Written by the US UK Tax Experts team, cross-border tax specialists
P11D benefits and US tax: an introduction
P11D benefits and US tax do not line up neatly. Most UK perks are also taxable income on a US return, but the IRS values them its own way, and it exempts some that HMRC taxes. So you cannot copy the P11D figures onto Form 1040. Each benefit has to be valued again under US rules.
This guide supports our pillar on US-UK tax for founders and executives, which covers pay, equity and bonuses across both systems. Here we look only at the non-cash perks that HMRC lists on a P11D.
Why P11D benefits and US tax cause friction
The P11D is an HMRC form that employers file each July. It shows a cash equivalent for each perk, worked out under UK rules. American executives often hand it to their US preparer, who simply adds the total to wages. That is usually wrong in both directions. Some benefits are overstated for US purposes, and one common perk is not taxable in the US at all.
Terms used in this guide
A benefit in kind is a non-cash perk an employer provides, such as a car or medical cover. The P11D is the HMRC return that reports benefits in kind not taxed through payroll. Payrolling is the alternative, where the employer taxes the benefit through monthly pay instead. Fair market value is the US measure for most benefits: what you would pay for the same thing in an arm's length deal.
Are UK benefits in kind taxable on a US return?
Mostly, yes. US law taxes all compensation, whatever form it takes, unless a specific rule excludes it. The difference lies in how much is taxed, not whether.
The US starting point
Gross income under 26 U.S.C. section 61 includes fringe benefits. The regulation at 26 CFR 1.61-21 says a taxable fringe is included at fair market value, less anything you paid for it. The IRS Publication 15-B explains the main valuation methods for employers.
The UK starting point
GOV.UK's page on tax on company benefits lists cars, accommodation and loans among the taxable perks. HMRC uses fixed formulas rather than market value for many of them. A company car, for example, is taxed on a percentage of its list price set by its emissions. That formula has no counterpart in US law.
Benefits as foreign earned income
Benefits you receive for work done in the UK are foreign earned income for US purposes. The IRS Publication 54 confirms this, noting that the source of pay is where you perform the work. So the foreign earned income exclusion and the foreign tax credit both apply to them. Which one you use shapes the answer to most P11D benefits and US tax questions.
How is a UK company car valued for US tax?
Only the personal use counts, and it is valued at its US fair market value, usually through the IRS annual lease value table. The UK list-price percentage plays no part.
The UK charge
The GOV.UK guidance on company cars explains that tax depends on the list price, the CO2 emissions and the fuel type. Private use is assumed if the car is available for it. An electric car can carry a very low charge, while a large diesel can carry a high one.
The US charge
The US regulation offers an annual lease value method, based on the car's fair market value. That value is then reduced to the share of mileage that was personal. Commuting counts as personal in both countries. Business mileage is excluded as a working condition fringe. A good mileage log is therefore worth more on the US side than the UK side.
Fuel
Free private fuel is a separate charge in the UK, again on a formula. In the US, fuel the employer pays for personal miles is added at its actual value. The annual lease value tables exclude fuel, so it is valued on top.

What about medical cover, loans and housing?
Private medical insurance is usually not taxable in the US. Cheap loans are taxed under a separate US rule with its own limits. Employer-provided housing is taxable, but it may qualify for the US housing exclusion.
Private medical insurance
HMRC taxes employer-paid medical insurance as a benefit. The US generally excludes employer-provided coverage under an accident or health plan, under 26 U.S.C. section 106. In our view, a UK group policy paid by your employer normally falls within that exclusion. So the premium shown on the P11D usually stays off the US return.
Beneficial loans
A low-interest or interest-free loan from your employer is a UK benefit at the official rate of interest. In the US, compensation-related loans fall under 26 U.S.C. section 7872. That section has a $10,000 de minimis rule for such loans, and uses US federal rates, not the UK official rate. A loan can therefore be taxable in one country and not the other.
Accommodation
Publication 54 says you include the fair market value of housing your employer provides, usually the rent the employer pays. That amount is foreign earned income. If you use Form 2555, part of it may then qualify for the foreign housing exclusion. A narrow exclusion under section 119 covers lodging on the business premises for the employer's convenience, which rarely fits a London flat.
Consider a typical case: a finance director in Reading
Consider a typical case. Daniel is a US citizen and finance director for a UK company in Reading. In 2025 his P11D showed a car, private fuel and private medical insurance. The figures are an example, not a real client.
The P11D figures
His P11D showed a car benefit of £9,000, a fuel benefit of £6,500 and medical insurance of £1,400. That is £16,900 of benefits, taxed in the UK at his marginal rate through his tax code. His previous preparer had simply added the dollar value of £16,900 to his US wages.
Revaluing for the US
This is where P11D benefits and US tax part company. Daniel's mileage log showed 60% business use. Using the car's market value and the IRS lease value table, his personal use came to about £4,800. Fuel for personal miles was about £1,900 at actual cost. The medical cover came off entirely under section 106. So the US figure is about £6,700, not £16,900.
The credit side
Daniel claims the foreign tax credit on Form 1116. UK tax on the full £16,900 is still UK tax on his wages. However, the slice charged on the medical premium relates to income the US does not tax. We leave that slice out of the credit, which is the cautious approach. With UK rates above US rates at his level, Daniel still owes no US tax on his salary, and the excess credit carries forward.
What changes with payrolling from April 2027?
From 6 April 2027, employers must tax cars, fuel, vans and medical insurance through payroll instead of the P11D. Most other benefits follow from April 2028. The US rules do not change, but the paperwork your preparer works from will.
What HMRC has published
GOV.UK's guide to preparing for mandatory payrolling, published on 9 November 2026, sets out the phases. Phase one covers company cars and fuel, vans and fuel, and medical insurance from 6 April 2027. All other benefits except loans and accommodation follow from 6 April 2028. Payrolled benefits no longer go on the P11D or P11D(b).
Globally mobile employees
The same page says eligible globally mobile employees are exempt, but the employer must apply for an exception by 5 April 2027. Some American executives on assignment may fall into this group. If yours do, the P11D may continue for them a while longer.
Class 1A National Insurance
GOV.UK says employers will deduct income tax and account for Class 1A National Insurance in real time on payrolled benefits. Class 1A is an employer charge, so it never appears as your tax. It plays no part in your US foreign tax credit. What matters on your side is the income tax taken from your pay each month, which now includes tax on the payrolled benefits. Your payslips will therefore carry a larger tax figure than your cash pay alone would explain.
What it means for your US return
Once a benefit is payrolled, its UK value appears in your monthly pay records rather than on a year-end form. For P11D benefits and US tax purposes, ask your employer for a year-end breakdown of payrolled benefits by type. Without it, separating medical cover from car benefit becomes guesswork. Until April 2027, the current P11D deadline of 6 July still applies, including for giving you a copy.
What records do you need for P11D benefits and US tax?
Keep the P11D or payroll breakdown, a mileage log, the car's value and any housing or loan agreements. With those, each benefit can be valued twice, once for each country, and the gap explained.
For the car
Ask your fleet manager for the car's value when it was first provided to you. That figure feeds the annual lease value table. Keep a mileage log that separates business trips, commuting and private journeys. A monthly summary is enough if it is kept as you go. Reconstructing a year of journeys from memory rarely survives a question from either tax authority.
For medical cover
Keep the policy schedule showing that the employer pays the premium and who is covered. If family members are on the policy, the whole premium is still usually within the US exclusion. The UK charge, by contrast, covers the whole premium too. For P11D benefits and US tax purposes, the schedule is your evidence that the premium was employer-provided health cover rather than cash.
For housing and loans
Keep the tenancy agreement or the employer's letter showing the rent paid. For a loan, keep the agreement, the interest rate and the balance at each month end. These are the figures that drive the US calculations. The UK figures will already appear on the P11D, but the US side needs the underlying detail.
One working paper for both returns
We set out P11D benefits and US tax figures side by side, one row per benefit. The UK column carries the HMRC value. The US column carries the revalued figure and a short reason for the difference. That single page answers most questions either authority might ask, and it makes next year's return quicker. It also shows at a glance why P11D benefits and your US tax figure differ.
Which mistakes come up most often?
Adding the P11D total to US wages, forgetting the medical exclusion, and mismatching tax years. Each one is easy to avoid once you know to look.
Using HMRC values
The P11D figure is a UK statutory value, not a market value. Using it unchanged can overstate US income, especially for cars and fuel. Revalue each benefit, and keep the workings.
Tax-year mismatch
A P11D covers 6 April to 5 April. Your US return runs January to December. Each P11D therefore spans two US years. We split benefits by the months they were provided, which is simple for a car and harder for a one-off perk.
Forgetting the exclusion route
If you use the foreign earned income exclusion on Form 2555, revalued benefits count towards the cap, which is indexed each year. For high earners, the credit route is often the better fit, but the numbers decide. Our US federal returns service models both.
How US UK Tax Experts can help
We prepare your US return from your P11D or payroll records and revalue each benefit under US rules. We also prepare your UK Self Assessment where needed, so both returns start from one set of figures. For P11D benefits and US tax, that means one working paper showing the UK value, the US value and the reason for any gap.
Conclusion
UK perks are usually taxable in the US, but rarely at the P11D figure. Cars and fuel shrink to their personal use, medical cover usually drops out, and housing may qualify for the exclusion. Payrolling from April 2027 moves cars, fuel and medical cover from the P11D into payslips, with most other perks following in 2028, so ask for a breakdown early. For more on senior pay across both systems, see our guide for US-UK executives.
Contact us
Email hello@usuktaxexperts.com or use our contact form with your latest P11D and payslips. We reply within one working day.
Frequently asked questions
Usually yes, but not at the P11D value. Matching P11D benefits and US tax rules means each perk is revalued. US law taxes fringe benefits at fair market value unless a specific exclusion applies, so each perk is revalued under US rules before it goes on the return.
Generally not. Section 106 excludes employer-provided coverage under an accident or health plan, and in our view a UK group policy paid by your employer normally qualifies. It remains taxable in the UK.
Only the personal use is taxed, valued at US fair market value, usually through the IRS annual lease value method. Commuting counts as personal use, and a mileage log supports the business share.
From 6 April 2027, UK employers must payroll company cars, fuel, vans and medical insurance instead of reporting them on a P11D. The US rules stay the same, but you will need a payroll breakdown by benefit type to revalue each one.
Yes, for UK tax on benefits the US also taxes. Tax charged on a benefit the US excludes, such as medical cover, is best left out of the credit as the cautious approach.
It can. Publication 54 says you include the fair market value of employer-provided housing in income, usually the rent paid. If you use Form 2555, part of it may then qualify for the housing exclusion.
They can be, under section 7872, which has a $10,000 de minimis rule for compensation-related loans and uses US federal rates. So a loan may be taxed differently in each country.





