US UKTax Experts
All insights
US TAX9 min read

P800 Refund and US Tax: What an HMRC Tax Calculation Letter Means for Your US Return

HMRC sends P800 letters between June and November. For an American who claims the foreign tax credit, a refund of overpaid PAYE can reach back into a US return already filed. Here is when it does, when it does not, and what to file.

Young woman in a terraced house hallway opening a brown envelope, checking a P800 refund and US tax effect

A P800 often arrives in the autumn, months after the US return for the same income has already been filed.

Written by the US UK Tax Experts team, cross-border tax specialists

P800 refund and US tax: an introduction

A P800 refund and US tax interact only if you claimed a US foreign tax credit for the UK tax that HMRC is now paying back. In that case the refund is a foreign tax redetermination, and your US credit for that year must shrink. If you used the foreign earned income exclusion on those wages instead, the refund usually changes nothing on your US return.

This guide supports our pillar on US and UK tax returns, which explains how the two returns fit together each year. Here we look at one small letter that causes a surprising amount of work for Americans on UK payroll.

Why P800 refund and US tax questions arise every autumn

Most Americans in Britain who work for an employer pay tax through PAYE. Tax codes go wrong, especially after a job change. HMRC then checks the year and sends a P800, often after you have filed your US return. The timing is what turns a welcome refund into a US question. By then the US return may be filed and the credit already claimed. That is the moment the P800 refund and US tax link matters.

Terms used in this guide

A P800 is HMRC's tax calculation letter for employees and pensioners. A foreign tax credit is a US credit for income tax paid to another country, claimed on Form 1116. A foreign tax redetermination is any later change in the foreign tax you paid, including a refund. The cash method credits foreign tax in the year paid, and the accrual method credits it in the year it accrues.

What is a P800 and when does HMRC send one?

A P800 tells you that you paid too much or too little tax through PAYE in a tax year ending on 5 April. HMRC sends them between June and the end of November. People registered for Self Assessment do not receive them, because their return adjusts the tax instead.

Who receives one

GOV.UK's page on tax overpayments and underpayments says the letters go to employees and people receiving a pension. Common causes are the wrong tax code or a new job starting while the old one still paid you. Two jobs at once, or a benefit in kind added late, can do the same.

How the refund is paid

HMRC's page for people due a refund gives the timings. An online claim pays within 5 working days. A cheque you ask for takes about 6 weeks. If the letter says a cheque is on its way, it arrives within 14 days of the letter's date. Note the date the money reaches you, because that date matters for the US return. Keep the bank statement that shows it. A screenshot of the HMRC confirmation helps too.

How an underpayment is collected

If you owe tax, HMRC usually changes your tax code for the following year. The guidance on paying tax you owe says this applies where you owe less than £3,000 and earn enough to cover it. The extra tax is then taken in equal instalments over twelve months. Larger amounts usually come through a Simple Assessment letter instead.

Does a P800 refund change your US tax return?

Only if you claimed a foreign tax credit for the refunded tax. A refund of creditable foreign tax requires a redetermination of the credit under section 905(c). If the refunded tax related to wages you excluded, there was no credit to reduce.

The rule for refunds

The regulation at 26 CFR 1.905-1(c)(4) says a refund of tax credited on the cash basis requires a redetermination of foreign tax paid and of US tax. The statute is 26 U.S.C. section 905(c), with the detail in 26 CFR 1.905-3. In plain terms, you can only keep a credit for tax HMRC actually keeps.

When the exclusion was used instead

Many employees use the foreign earned income exclusion on Form 2555. Foreign tax on excluded wages cannot be credited. So for them, a P800 refund and US tax have no link, and nothing needs amending. The IRS explains the exclusion on its foreign earned income exclusion page.

When the US return is not yet filed

Sometimes the refund arrives before you file the US return that would have claimed the tax. Then the simplest course is to claim only the net UK tax you kept. No later amendment is needed, because the original return already reflects the refund. This is common when the overpayment came from the last months of the UK tax year. For example, a January job change can produce a refund by the summer. If your US return is still on extension, the fix is easy.

Closed laptop, coffee mug and calculator on a rainy windowsill desk, set up to work out a P800 refund and US tax change
Most P800 adjustments are small, yet each one has to be traced to the US year in which the refunded tax was first credited.

Which US year does the refund affect?

That depends on whether you claim the credit on the cash or the accrual basis. Under the cash basis, it affects the US years in which the refunded tax was withheld. Under the accrual basis, it affects the US year in which the UK tax year ended.

Cash-basis filers

Under the cash method, withheld tax is treated as paid in the year it is withheld. A UK tax year runs from 6 April to 5 April, so PAYE for one UK year spans two US years. In our approach, the refund is matched to the months when the excess tax was taken. Where that is unclear, we spread it in proportion to the PAYE credited in each US year.

Accrual-basis filers

The regulation says tax based on a foreign tax year becomes fixed at the close of that year. UK tax for 2025/26 therefore accrues on 5 April 2026, in the US 2026 year. A P800 for 2025/26 then reduces the 2026 credit only. Electing the accrual method is irrevocable once made, though a first-time claimant may elect it on an amended return.

Underpayments work differently

Suppose the P800 shows tax owed instead, collected through next year's tax code. Under the cash method, extra tax relating to an earlier year is credited only in the year you pay it, according to 1.905-1(c)(4). So the earlier US return stays as it is. Under the accrual method, the extra tax relates back to its UK year, and a refund claim for that US year may follow.

What do you file after a P800 refund?

If the refund increases your US tax for an earlier year, you file an amended return with a revised Form 1116. If it changes no year's US tax, a statement can do instead. Either way, a P800 refund and US tax adjustment has a deadline.

The amended return and its deadline

Under 26 CFR 1.905-4(b), an individual notifies the IRS by filing an amended return with Form 1116 and a statement. Where US tax goes up, the deadline is the due date, including extensions, of your original return for the year the refund arrived. The amended return itself is Form 1040-X.

When a statement is enough

The same regulation lets you attach a statement to your original return where the redetermination changes no year's US tax. That often happens when UK tax was well above US tax and you carry excess credits forward. Even then, the carryover itself falls, so your records must show the new figure. Several refunds affecting one year can be dealt with in one amended return.

The penalty for ignoring it

Failing to notify the IRS of a redetermination can bring a penalty under 26 U.S.C. section 6689. The tax itself is usually small for a P800, so the penalty risk is easily avoided. It is the paperwork, not the amount, that people forget.

Two refunds in one year

Some people receive two P800s close together, one for each of two UK years. Each refund is traced separately. One may touch your 2024 US return and the other your 2025 return. The regulation lets you combine several redeterminations for the same US year in one amended return. Still, a P800 refund and US tax adjustment for two different US years means two separate filings or statements. Keep each letter with a note of the US year it affects.

Consider a typical case: a job change in Leeds

Consider a typical case. Sophie is a US citizen working as a hospital pharmacist in Leeds. She claims the foreign tax credit on the cash basis rather than the exclusion. The figures below are an example, not a real client.

What went wrong

Sophie changed employer in May 2025. Her new employer used an emergency code until August, so she overpaid about £1,100. All of that excess was withheld between May and August 2025. She filed her 2025 US return in June 2026, crediting all the PAYE withheld in 2025.

The P800 arrives

In September 2026 HMRC sent a P800 for 2025/26 showing the £1,100 overpayment. Sophie claimed online and received the money within a week. Because the excess was withheld in 2025, the refund reduces her 2025 credit. At the rates used on her 2025 Form 1116, it is worth roughly $1,450.

What she files

Sophie's UK tax on her salary was well above her US tax, and she had excess credits carried forward. Removing $1,450 of credit does not change her 2025 US tax. Therefore, under the no-change rule, she attaches a statement to her 2026 return and reduces her carryover. Had her US tax risen, she would have filed Form 1040-X by the 2026 return's extended due date. Her P800 refund and US tax position is settled in one page. Next year, her preparer starts from the reduced carryover. Nothing else on her return moves.

What should you check when a P800 arrives?

Check which tax year it covers, whether it is a refund or a bill, and how you treated those wages on your US return. Those three facts tell you whether anything US-side needs doing. Most of the time the answer is quick.

Check the HMRC figures first

Compare the P800 with your P60 and payslips. If the letter misses a benefit or a pension contribution, tell HMRC which figures are wrong. There is little point adjusting your US return for a refund that HMRC may later reverse. GOV.UK explains how tax codes work if the code was the cause.

Then check your US method

Look at your Form 1116 for the years concerned. Did you credit the PAYE, or exclude the wages on Form 2555? Did you tick the box electing the accrual method? The answers decide which year a P800 refund and US tax adjustment belongs to. The IRS foreign tax credit page covers the basics.

Keep the paper trail

Keep the P800, the date the refund reached your account, and any revised P60. Note the exchange rates used on the original Form 1116. With those, an amendment or statement takes an hour, not a weekend. Without them, it means rebuilding a year from bank statements.

How US UK Tax Experts can help

US UK Tax Experts prepares US and UK returns from one file, so the two agree. When a P800 arrives, we check it against your UK pay records and trace the refund to the right US year. We then prepare any Form 1040-X, revised Form 1116 or statement. Our US federal returns service and our UK Self Assessment service explain how we work.

Conclusion

A P800 refund is a refund of foreign tax. If you credited that tax on a US return, the credit must come down, either by amendment or by statement. Your choice of cash or accrual basis decides which year moves. Underpayments collected through a tax code are credited when paid under the cash method. The rules on double taxation relief work well, but only if each refund is followed through. Handled early, the P800 refund and US tax link takes very little time.

Contact us

If HMRC has sent you a P800 and you file a US return, email hello@usuktaxexperts.com or use our contact page. Send the letter, your P60 and your last US return. We reply within one working day.

Frequently asked questions

Only if you claimed a US foreign tax credit for the tax HMRC refunded. The refund is then a foreign tax redetermination, and the credit for that year must be reduced. If you excluded those wages on Form 2555, nothing changes.

You do if the refund increases your US tax for an earlier year. If it changes no year's US tax, for example because you carry excess credits forward, a statement can be attached to your return instead. The carryover still falls.

Where US tax goes up, the deadline is the due date, including extensions, of your original US return for the year the refund arrived. That gives most people well over a year. The P800 refund and US tax amendment should still be done promptly.

On the cash basis, the US years in which the refunded tax was withheld. On the accrual basis, the US year in which the UK tax year ended on 5 April. Your Form 1116 shows which method you use.

HMRC usually collects amounts under £3,000 through next year's tax code. Under the cash method, the extra tax is credited in the US year you pay it, and the earlier return stays unchanged. Accrual-basis filers may instead claim it for the earlier year.

Within 5 working days if you claim online, or about 6 weeks if you ask for a cheque. If the letter says a cheque is coming, it arrives within 14 days of the letter's date. Note the date for your P800 refund and US tax records.

No. People registered for Self Assessment have over- or underpayments adjusted through their return, so they receive neither a P800 nor a Simple Assessment letter.

Have a question this does not answer?

Tell us the situation and we will tell you what needs filing, where, and by when.