US UKTax Experts
All insights
TAX GUIDE10 min read

The Saving Clause US UK Treaty Rule: What Americans in Britain Keep

One sentence in Article 1 lets the US tax its citizens as if the treaty did not exist. Here is what survives it, which return each surviving benefit appears on, and how the re-sourcing rule stops US dividends and interest being taxed twice.

Woman reading a bound document in a historic library, studying the saving clause US UK treaty wording

Most of the treaty reads well for a UK resident; the saving clause is the one sentence an American has to read first.

Written by the US UK Tax Experts team, cross-border tax specialists

Saving clause US UK treaty: an introduction

The saving clause US UK treaty rule lets the US tax its citizens almost as if the treaty did not exist. It sits in Article 1(4). So most articles that say income is "taxable only" in the UK do not protect an American living here. However, Article 1(5) keeps a short list of benefits, and those carry most of the weight.

This article supports our guide to the US-UK double taxation treaty. Rather than restate the clause, we sort what survives it by the return where it shows up. Then we work through the re-sourcing rule with figures. We prepare and file returns; we do not give investment advice.

What the saving clause US UK treaty text says

Start with the treaty text itself. Each country may tax its residents, and the US may tax its citizens, "as if this Convention had not come into effect". The only override is paragraph 5 of the same article. Consequently, every benefit you claim on a US return must appear in that paragraph. The alternative is an article that names citizens expressly.

Who this guide is for

We write for US citizens and green card holders living in the UK. It also matters if you have given up citizenship or a long-held green card. The clause can follow you for ten years. Britons living in America face the mirror image, since the UK has the same right over its own residents.

Which treaty benefits does a US citizen keep?

A US citizen keeps the benefits listed in Article 1(5)(a). They cover pensions, social security, child support, pension scheme growth, double tax relief, non-discrimination and the mutual agreement procedure.

The list in Article 1(5)(a)

The paragraph names Article 9(2) on associated enterprises and Article 17(1)(b), (3) and (5). It then names Article 18(1) and Articles 24, 25 and 26 in full. Treasury's Technical Explanation of the treaty describes these as the exceptions that apply whatever your status. Everything else, including the "taxable only" rules for interest, gains and employment income, falls away for a US citizen.

The list that citizens do not get

Article 1(5)(b) adds a second list. It covers Article 18(2) on pension contributions and Article 19 on government service. It also covers Article 20 on students and Article 28 on diplomats. Yet these apply only to people who are neither citizens nor green card holders. So a US citizen teaching in Britain cannot use the student or government service rules on the US return.

Articles written for citizens directly

A few articles name citizens. Because they name US citizens in their own text, the saving clause US UK treaty override does not stop them. Article 18(5) is one. It gives US relief for contributions a US citizen makes to a UK workplace pension through UK employment, within limits. Article 24(6) is another, and it does most of the work on US-source income.

Where does each surviving benefit appear?

Each benefit shows up on one return, and knowing which one saves wasted claims. Here is the sorting we use when preparing both returns from one file.

Benefits claimed on the UK return

Start with Social Security. Article 17(3) makes US Social Security paid to a UK resident taxable only in the UK. That works for a US citizen because 17(3) is on the exception list. Similarly, Article 17(1)(b) exempts a pension payment in the UK if the US would exempt it. A qualified Roth IRA withdrawal is the usual example. The claim sits on the UK return. HMRC's guidance on being taxed twice on foreign income explains how UK relief is given.

Benefits claimed on the US return

Pensions come first here. Article 18(1) stops the US taxing growth inside a UK pension until you draw from it. Article 18(5) gives a US deduction or exclusion for qualifying UK workplace pension contributions. Furthermore, Article 24 lets you credit UK tax and re-source certain income. These go on your US return. Some need disclosure on Form 8833, the IRS form for treaty-based return positions.

Benefits that need both returns to agree

Matching matters. Article 17(3) also stops the US taxing the same Social Security, so the US return should leave it out. Additionally, Article 26 lets you ask both tax authorities to resolve double taxation together. Article 25 protects you from discrimination as a national. In our experience, problems arise when one return claims a benefit and the other ignores it. Therefore, we check each claim against both returns at once. The saving clause US UK treaty override applies to the US return; the UK return follows its own law and the treaty.

Antique brass key in a green velvet box, a symbol of the saving clause US UK treaty exceptions
The exceptions in Article 1(5) are the few keys a US citizen in Britain still holds once the saving clause has locked the rest of the treaty.

How does Article 24(6) stop double tax on US income?

It splits the tax between the two countries in three steps. The US keeps only what it could charge a non-citizen. The UK credits that, and the US credits the UK tax that remains.

Step one: the UK credit is capped

The UK moves first. Under Article 24(6)(b), it credits only the US tax the treaty would allow on a non-citizen UK resident. For portfolio dividends, Article 10 allows the US 15% of the gross amount. For interest, Article 11 makes it taxable only in the country of residence, so the allowed US tax is nil. Consequently, the UK credits 15% on US dividends and nothing on US interest.

Step two: the US credits UK tax

The US moves next. It credits the UK tax paid after the UK's own credit, under Article 24(6)(c). That credit cannot reduce the part of US tax the UK has already credited. In plain terms, the US keeps its treaty share and gives back the rest where UK tax covers it.

Step three: the income is re-sourced

The US credit limit normally blocks credits against US-source income. So Article 24(6)(d) treats the income as arising in the UK. It does so only as far as needed to avoid double tax. On the US return, re-sourced income goes in its own Form 1116 category. The Form 1116 instructions call it income re-sourced by treaty, and re-sourced income from each treaty country needs a separate form. The instructions add that Form 8833 may also be needed.

A worked example: US dividends and interest

Consider a typical case. It is an example, not a real client, and the tax figures are assumptions chosen to show the steps. Daniel is a US citizen in Bath. In one year he receives $10,000 of dividends from US shares and $4,000 of interest from a US bank. He is a UK higher-rate taxpayer.

The dividends

Assume UK tax on the dividends of $3,575. The US could charge a non-citizen 15%, which is $1,500, so the UK credits $1,500. Daniel pays $2,075 to HMRC. Assume his US tax as a citizen on the dividends is also $1,500. That is the treaty share, which the US keeps. No further US credit is needed, and his total tax is the $3,575 UK charge.

The interest

Assume UK tax on the interest of $1,600. The treaty would let the US charge a non-citizen nothing, so the UK gives no credit. Daniel pays the full $1,600 to HMRC. Next, assume US tax as a citizen of $960. The US credits the UK tax after re-sourcing the interest as UK income. His US tax on the interest falls to nil, and his total is the $1,600 UK charge.

What the example shows

Compare the two results. Without re-sourcing, Daniel would pay $960 to the US and $1,600 to the UK on the same interest. With it, the saving clause US UK treaty override still lets the US tax him. However, the credit absorbs the charge. Moreover, the order matters. The UK return must be settled first, because the US credit depends on UK tax after the UK credit. We follow that order every year.

Does the saving clause apply after you renounce?

It can, for ten years and only on US-source income. Article 1(6) applies where giving up citizenship or long-term residence had tax avoidance as one of its principal purposes.

The ten-year rule

Article 1(6) sets the rule. It covers a former citizen or long-term resident who gave up status with tax avoidance as a principal purpose. That person is treated as a citizen for ten years. The test uses the law of the country they left. However, the rule reaches only income from sources in that country. It does not apply to anyone who lost the status before 6 February 1995.

How it links to the exit tax rules

US domestic law has its own regime for people who expatriate. The IRS page on the expatriation tax explains who is a covered expatriate and the role of Form 8854. Article 24(6) also names former citizens and long-term residents, so the credit steps can still apply to them. Our expatriation service prepares the final returns and Form 8854. Before you renounce, therefore, check how the saving clause US UK treaty rule would treat any US income you keep. A US pension, US rental income or US shares are the usual examples.

Long-term residents and the treaty tie-breaker

Green card holders face a related risk. A long-term resident held the card in at least 8 of 15 tax years, under section 877(e). Suppose such a person claims UK treaty residence and does not waive the benefits. The IRS then treats US residence as ended for tax purposes. As a result, a green card holder should not claim UK treaty residence lightly. The saving clause US UK treaty rule is not the only trap here.

What do people get wrong about the saving clause?

The most common mistake is reading a "taxable only in the UK" article and leaving the income off the US return. A close second is claiming a benefit on the wrong return.

Gains on UK shares and property

Article 13 gives the residence country the right to tax most gains. But it is not on the exception list. So a US citizen in Britain still reports gains on UK shares and a UK home to the IRS. The relief comes from credits, not exemption. Our guide to UK capital gains for US persons covers the mismatch in detail. Under the saving clause US UK treaty rule, a gain the UK taxes first is still a gain on your Form 1040.

UK salary and the employment article

Salary is the next trap. Article 14 lets the UK tax UK employment, and sometimes makes it taxable only there. For a US citizen, the saving clause removes that protection. Instead, you use the foreign earned income exclusion or the foreign tax credit. Our comparison of the FEIE and the foreign tax credit shows how to choose.

Green card holders and Article 4(2)

Residence is the last trap. Under Article 4(2), a citizen or green card holder is a treaty resident of the US only with real ties there. Those ties are a substantial presence, permanent home or habitual abode. Therefore, an American who lives only in Britain is usually a UK resident under the treaty. Nevertheless, the saving clause still lets the US tax citizens. For green card holders, residence carries the expatriation risk described above.

How US UK Tax Experts can help

US UK Tax Experts prepares your US and UK returns from one file. That matters for the saving clause US UK treaty rules. The credit steps run from one return to the other. We settle the UK figures first, then apply the US credit and any re-sourcing. In addition, we check each treaty claim against both returns and prepare Form 8833 where a disclosure is needed. Our treaty relief service covers the claims, and our US UK tax returns guide covers the wider picture.

Conclusion

The saving clause removes most of the treaty for a US citizen in Britain. What remains is short but valuable. It covers pension protection, Social Security taxed only in the UK, double tax relief and joint resolution. Furthermore, Article 24(6) re-sources US income so the credit can work. Read the exception list first, then decide which return each claim belongs on. The IRS keeps the treaty, protocol and Technical Explanation together on its United Kingdom tax treaty documents page.

Contact us

Are you unsure which treaty claims you can make under the saving clause US UK treaty rules? Email us at hello@usuktaxexperts.com or use our contact form. Tell us your income types and your last two returns. We reply within one working day.

Frequently asked questions

It is Article 1(4), which lets each country tax its residents, and the US tax its citizens, as if the treaty did not exist. Article 1(5) then lists the benefits that survive it. For a US citizen in Britain, it means most treaty exemptions do not apply on the US return.

Article 9(2), Article 17(1)(b), (3) and (5), Article 18(1), and Articles 24, 25 and 26. Articles that name US citizens directly, such as Article 18(5), also apply. Student, teacher and government service rules do not apply to citizens or green card holders.

Only in the UK, and the saving clause US UK treaty override does not change that. Article 17(3) makes social security paid by one country to a resident of the other taxable only in the residence country, and it is a saving clause exception. The US return should therefore leave it out of taxable income.

Under Article 24(6), the UK credits only the US tax the treaty would allow on a non-citizen, and the US credits the UK tax that remains. To make the US credit work, the income is treated as UK-source to the extent needed. It is reported in its own Form 1116 category.

It can apply for ten years if tax avoidance was one of the principal purposes of giving up citizenship. The rule reaches only US-source income. It does not apply to people who lost citizenship before 6 February 1995.

Sometimes. Form 8833 discloses a treaty-based position on the US return, and some positions are exempt from disclosure under the regulations. Where a US citizen relies on a treaty article to change the US result, we review whether disclosure is needed.

Yes, under the tie-breaker, but it has consequences. For a long-term resident, claiming UK treaty residence without waiving the benefits is treated as ending US residence for tax purposes. That can bring the expatriation rules and Form 8854 into play.

Have a question this does not answer?

Tell us the situation and we will tell you what needs filing, where, and by when.