US UKTax Experts
All insights
BUSINESS TAX11 min read

Treaty Limitation on Benefits: When a UK Company or Trust Can Claim the US-UK Treaty

Being registered in Britain does not by itself let a UK company or trust cut US withholding. Article 23 of the US-UK treaty asks who owns it and where its income goes. Here is how each test works and which W-8BEN-E box follows.

Two business owners at an oak table reviewing papers on their treaty limitation on benefits claim

For a family-owned UK company, treaty relief on US income turns on who owns it and where its profits flow, not just where it is registered.

Written by the US UK Tax Experts team, cross-border tax specialists

Treaty limitation on benefits: an introduction

The treaty limitation on benefits rule is Article 23 of the US-UK income tax treaty. It decides whether a UK company, trust or pension scheme may use the treaty at all. Being resident in Britain is only the entry ticket. The entity must also be a "qualified person" or pass a fallback route. Only then will the US cut its withholding on dividends, interest or royalties.

This guide supports our pillar on the US-UK double taxation treaty. Here we stay with entities: the family company, the holding company and the British trust. Each receives US income and must hand a Form W-8BEN-E to the US payer.

Why treaty limitation on benefits matters to small companies

Large groups have tax departments that live with these rules. Smaller owners meet the treaty limitation on benefits rules when a US bank or customer sends a W-8BEN-E. The form asks which box applies. Tick the wrong one and the payer may withhold the full statutory rate. For most investment income of a foreign corporation, that rate is 30% under section 881 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Terms used in this guide

A qualified person is a UK or US resident meeting a test in Article 23(2). An equivalent beneficiary is a resident of certain listed countries. That person must get equally good treaty treatment on the same income. Base erosion means paying away deductible amounts, such as interest or fees, to people outside both countries. A withholding agent is the US payer that deducts tax before paying you.

What does the US-UK limitation on benefits article actually test?

The treaty limitation on benefits article tests ownership and the flow of income. Article 23 assumes benefits belong to genuine UK or US residents. Outsiders routing income through a British shell should not get them. So each test asks who stands behind the entity, or whether it runs a real business at home.

The structure of Article 23

Paragraph 1 limits benefits to qualified persons, unless another paragraph helps. Paragraph 2 lists the qualified persons. Paragraph 3 adds derivative benefits for companies, and paragraph 4 an active trade or business test. Paragraph 6 lets the competent authority grant relief case by case. You can read every paragraph in the treaty text published by the US Treasury.

Who qualifies automatically

Individuals qualify without more. So do qualified governmental entities. A company qualifies if its principal class of shares is listed on a recognised exchange and regularly traded. A company also qualifies if five or fewer listed companies own at least 50% of its votes and value. Most private British companies fail these listed tests, so they move on to the ownership test.

Pension schemes and charities

Article 4(3) treats pension schemes, benefit plans and charities as residents. That holds even when they pay no tax. Article 23(2)(e) then makes them qualified persons. For a pension scheme or benefit plan there is a condition. More than half of its beneficiaries, members or participants must be individuals resident in the UK or the US.

Can a family-owned UK company pass the ownership and base erosion test?

Usually, yes. This is the treaty limitation on benefits test most private companies use. Article 23(2)(f) has two limbs, and an owner-managed company with British or American shareholders often meets both. The detail lies in the ownership chain and in where the deductible payments go.

The ownership limb

Qualified persons must own at least 50% of the votes and value, directly or indirectly. That must hold on at least half the days of the period. Under the treaty text, those owners can be residents of either country. A UK company owned by American individuals living in New York can still pass. That differs from the generic summary in the IRS form instructions, which describes owners resident in the company's own country. The treaty wording governs, so read the article itself.

The base erosion limb

Deductible payments to people outside both countries must stay under 50% of gross income. Arm's-length payments for services or goods in the ordinary course of business do not count. Bank interest is also excluded, provided a non-resident bank lends through a UK or US branch. For example, heavy interest paid to a relative's company in Jersey could fail this limb.

Holding companies and longer chains

Indirect ownership counts, so you trace shares up to the individuals at the top. Draw the chain before choosing a box. A British holding company owned by a Guernsey trust needs more thought than one owned by two siblings in Leeds. In the trust case, the trust's own treaty status and its beneficiaries both matter.

Hand sketching a UK company ownership chart on a whiteboard for a limitation on benefits test
Mapping each shareholder up the chain is the first step in deciding which limitation on benefits box the company can tick on Form W-8BEN-E.

When can a British trust claim the treaty?

A trust qualifies if qualified persons or equivalent beneficiaries hold at least 50% of the beneficial interest. It must also pass its own base erosion test. Article 23(2)(g) sets both conditions.

Who counts as a beneficial owner of the trust

Individuals resident in either country count. So do listed companies and qualifying pension schemes. Equivalent beneficiaries also count for trusts, which gives some flexibility. Discretionary trusts are harder, because nobody has a fixed share. In practice, preparers document who can benefit and where each person lives. Keep that record with the trust's tax papers.

Grantor trusts are a different question

US rules may treat the trust as owned by its settlor. It is then usually transparent for US purposes. The treaty claim then usually belongs to the person treated as owner, not to the trust. That is a classification question to settle first. Our guide to the saving clause in the US-UK treaty explains why an American settlor gains little here anyway.

Which W-8BEN-E box a trust uses

The LOB boxes on Form W-8BEN-E are written with companies in mind. The instructions provide an "Other" box for a test the list does not name, with the test written in. A trust relying on Article 23(2)(g) would normally use that box and cite the paragraph as its treaty limitation on benefits test. Explain the choice in your file, because a withholding agent may ask.

What are the fallback routes if a company is not a qualified person?

There are three: derivative benefits, the active business test and a discretionary grant. They sit in paragraphs 3, 4 and 6. Each works differently, and the first two apply item by item rather than to the whole company.

Derivative benefits and the 95% rule

Paragraph 3 needs seven or fewer equivalent beneficiaries owning at least 95% of the votes and value. It must also pass a base erosion test measured against equivalent beneficiaries. The treaty defines equivalent beneficiaries by reference to EU, EEA and NAFTA residents. For dividends, interest and royalties, each one also needs a rate at least as low under its own treaty.

Brexit and NAFTA did not break the test

Brexit raised a doubt over whether British residents still counted. In July 2021 the tax authorities said yes in a competent authority arrangement on UK withdrawal from the EU. A companion arrangement on the USMCA reads NAFTA references as references to its successor. HMRC lists both on its USA tax treaties page on GOV.UK.

The active trade or business test

Paragraph 4 helps a company that runs a real business in the UK. The US income must arise in connection with that business, or be incidental to it. Making or managing investments for your own account does not count, unless you are a bank, insurer or securities dealer. Where the income comes from a related US business, the UK activity must be substantial compared with it.

Asking the competent authority

Paragraph 6 is the last resort when every other treaty limitation on benefits route fails. The US competent authority can grant benefits where treaty access was not a principal purpose of the company. The W-8BEN-E instructions say you generally cannot claim those benefits while the request is still pending. Plan for full withholding in the meantime.

Why do the dividend rates depend on which test you pass?

Because Article 10 ties its best rate to particular routes. US withholding on dividends is generally capped at 15%. A company holding 10% or more of the votes gets 5%. A 0% rate exists, but the gate to it is narrow.

The 0% rate for 80% subsidiaries

Article 10(3) removes US tax for a UK company holding 80% of the votes for twelve months. The company must also meet one of three further conditions. It held the stake before 1 October 1998, or it passes the listed-company rules. Otherwise it needs paragraph 3 or 6 of Article 23. Passing the ownership and base erosion test alone is not on that list.

What that means for owner-managed groups

A UK holding company owned by individuals normally reaches the 5% rate, not 0%. Derivative benefits rarely rescue it, because an individual shareholder would face a higher rate on a direct dividend. So the "at least as low" condition fails. That is our reading of the text; groups with large dividends should confirm it before relying on any rate. The IRS tax treaty tables give the headline rates. Meanwhile, Table 4 on limitation on benefits lists the tests treaty by treaty.

Interest and royalties

Articles 11 and 12 leave US interest and royalties taxable only in the UK. That applies when a UK resident beneficially owns them. Both still depend on the treaty limitation on benefits rules. A UK company that fails every test is back at 30% on that income.

Which forms carry a treaty limitation on benefits claim?

Mainly Form W-8BEN-E, handed to the US payer rather than filed with the IRS. Sometimes Form 8833 is also needed with a US return. The payer then reports what it paid and withheld on Form 1042-S.

Completing Part III of the W-8BEN-E

On line 14a you name the United Kingdom as your treaty country. On line 14b you tick one treaty limitation on benefits box, such as the ownership and base erosion test. The IRS instructions for Form W-8BEN-E explain each box. Line 15 is for extra conditions, such as the ownership share behind the 5% dividend rate. There you cite Article 10(2)(a) and state the percentage held.

How long the form lasts

A W-8BEN-E generally lasts until the end of the third calendar year after signing. A change in circumstances ends it sooner. Selling shares, a new investor or a move of management can all change the LOB answer. The W-8BEN-E form page carries the current revision.

When Form 8833 comes in

Treasury regulation 26 CFR 301.6114-1 requires disclosure in some LOB cases. One is where a company relies on the LOB article and receives treaty-reduced income over $500,000 from a related party. Several waivers apply where Form 1042-S already reports the payment. Under section 6712, a missed disclosure costs $1,000, or $10,000 for a C corporation. The Form 8833 page has the form.

A worked example: Oliver and Grace's UK company

Consider a typical case. Oliver and Grace are siblings who own all the shares in a UK trading company based in Bristol. Oliver is British and UK resident. Grace is a US citizen who also lives in Bristol. The company licenses software to an unrelated US distributor for $80,000 a year in royalties. It also owns 100% of a US sales subsidiary, which declares a $200,000 dividend.

Testing the company

Both owners are individuals resident in a treaty country. So the ownership limb is met all year. The company's largest deductible payment abroad is a licence fee to a Swiss software house. That fee is under 20% of gross income, so the base erosion limb is met too. The company ticks the ownership and base erosion box on line 14b.

The withholding result

The royalties fall under Article 12, so US withholding drops from $24,000 at 30% to nil. The dividend is different. The company has held 100% for years, but it is not listed and derivative benefits do not fit. So the 5% rate applies: $10,000 withheld instead of $60,000. Line 15 cites Article 10(2)(a) and the 100% voting stake. The related-party dividend is below $500,000, so no Form 8833 disclosure is triggered for the LOB claim on these figures.

Grace's own filings

Grace owns half of a foreign company, so she files Form 5471 with her US return. Our guide to Form 5471 for a UK company explains which schedules she needs. The company's treaty position and her personal reporting are separate questions, but they use the same ownership facts.

How US UK Tax Experts can help

US UK Tax Experts prepares treaty limitation on benefits paperwork from one file. We map the ownership chain and work out which test the entity meets. Then we complete the W-8BEN-E and any Form 8833. For the owners, we prepare the US and UK returns that sit alongside it, including Form 5471. Our treaty relief service covers the forms, and our hub for founders and executives explains the wider filings. For individual investors, see our guide to US dividend withholding for UK residents. We prepare and file; we do not advise on restructuring.

Conclusion

Article 23 asks two questions: who owns the entity, and where its deductible payments go. Most family-owned UK companies pass the ownership and base erosion route. Trusts and holding companies need their chains traced. The best dividend rate needs more than that route, so check Article 10 before assuming 0%. Above all, keep the treaty limitation on benefits facts on file and refresh the W-8BEN-E when they change.

Contact us

Need a W-8BEN-E or Form 8833 prepared for your UK company or trust? Email hello@usuktaxexperts.com or use our contact form. We reply within one working day.

Frequently asked questions

It is Article 23, an anti-treaty-shopping rule. A UK resident company, trust or scheme gets treaty benefits from the US only if it is a qualified person or passes a fallback test. The tests look at who owns the entity and where its deductible payments go.

Often, through the ownership and base erosion test. Qualified persons, such as individuals resident in the UK or US, must own at least 50% of the votes and value on at least half the days of the year. Less than 50% of gross income may go to outsiders as deductible payments.

Only in narrow cases. Article 10(3) needs an 80% voting stake held for twelve months, plus listed-company status, a pre-October 1998 holding, derivative benefits or a competent authority grant. Most owner-managed holding companies receive the 5% rate instead.

Yes. A July 2021 competent authority arrangement between the IRS and HMRC confirmed that UK residents still count for the derivative benefits test. A companion arrangement reads the treaty's NAFTA references as references to the USMCA.

Usually the Other box, naming Article 23(2)(g) as the test relied on. The listed boxes are drafted for companies and public bodies. Keep a note of the beneficiaries and their residence to support the choice.

The US payer withholds at the statutory rate, which is 30% for most investment income of a foreign corporation. The company can still ask the US competent authority for a discretionary grant. It generally cannot claim the benefit while that request is pending.

Sometimes. Disclosure is generally required where a company relies on an LOB article and receives more than $500,000 of treaty-reduced income from a related party in the year. Several waivers apply where the payment is properly reported on Form 1042-S.

Have a question this does not answer?

Tell us the situation and we will tell you what needs filing, where, and by when.